Skip to content

FIFA Women's World Cup – Underway!

The FIFA Women’s World Cup is under way.  Australia have had success in the first game versus Ireland 1:0 albeit with the unfortunate loss of captain Sam Kerr to injury.

The injury that many sports persons dread and is relatively common in many sports is a rupture to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL).  This blog focuses on the ACL and how physicians working at Ballarat Sports Medicine and BallaratOSM can assist athletes with ACL injuries.

ACL Injuries

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are unpredictable. Most of them happen in harmless situations the athlete has been in hundreds of times before without it resulting in injury.

What many people do not know is, that we have two cruciate ligaments: An anterior and a posterior. Both are essential for stabilizing the knee. The anterior cruciate ligament is the one we hear most about. Unfortunately, usually after an injury has occurred.

This type of injury leads to a lengthy time away from sport (often up to 12 months) and increases the risk of osteoarthritis. Therefore, it is important that prevention of this type injury is a priority and if it does occur, that the right treatment is followed.

The knee’s safety belt

The ACL is a ligament in the centre of the knee that functions as a safety belt to prevent unwanted movements. A tear in the ACL is far more common than in the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) and injuries to the former usually have a greater impact on knee function.

ACL injuries are especially common in sports that involve sudden changes in direction such as soccer. Female athletes have up to 3 times higher risk of an ACL injury than men and they are often injured at a young age.

Characteristics of a torn cruciate ligament

A typical characteristic of a cruciate ligament injury is swelling, which occurs soon after a twisting movement, and a sensation of giving way. It can also be difficult to straighten out the leg or bend the knee more than 80 to 90 degrees. You should have a medical examination if you show any of these signs.  This can be arranged quickly with Sport & Exercise Medicine physician, Dr Greg Harris, or Sport & Exercise Medicine Registrar, Dr Jai Sharma at Ballarat Sports Medicine.

Additional injuries

Often, other structures such as the meniscus, cartilage, bone, and collateral ligaments, are also affected following a cruciate ligament injury. These additional injuries can often account for many of the symptoms following a torn cruciate ligament, and they can affect treatment options and the long-term prognosis. As such, it is important to have an MRI examination and get a specialist’s opinion soon after the incident.


Surgery following an ACL injury is not a given. On the contrary, about 50% of ACL injuries are treated conservatively (rehabilitation without surgery). Many of these show good results.

An orthopaedic surgeon will evaluate whether or not knee surgery is required following an ACL injury. The decision is based on symptoms and the athlete’s requirements for knee function in the future. That means that surgery is more common for an elite soccer player.  Independent surgeons, Mr David Mitchell and Mr Luke Spencer have subspeciality interest in knee injuries and can be seen quickly at BallaratOSM for ACL injuries.

It is recommended that athletes who don’t have any serious additional injuries try intensive training in conjunction with a physiotherapist for up to 3 months before surgery is considered. This will make it easier to predict whether the operation will have a good outcome, and rehabilitation will be more efficient.  Luke Blunden, Peta Johnston and Simon Lewis are all highly skilled at assisting athletes at Ballarat Sports Medicine pre-operatively and post operatively with ACL injuries.


The surgery involves replacing the injured ligament with tissue graft taken from the anterior or posterior thigh muscles. The surgery is done with an arthroscope using small incisions, which means that it is not necessary for the surgeon to completely open the knee.


Rehabilitation with a physiotherapist is tough following an ACL injury whether or not surgery is involved. Close monitoring of the training program is, therefore, important to manage all aspects of rehabilitation and a follow-up period of at least 6 to 12 months is recommended.

Rehabilitation focuses on regaining strength, mobility, balance, and control. The exercises are gradually made more difficult, and as function improves, more geared towards a functional return to the athlete’s sport.

For each extra month of post-surgery rehabilitation, the risk of re-injury is reduced by 50%.  The athlete should pass a variety of sport-specific tests to check whether their knee is ready for returning to sport. But this in itself is not enough; the athlete should also feel that they are ready. It is important that the athlete is not overly worried about re-injury and that they can trust their knee.

The decision to return to sport should be made in consultation with the doctor, physiotherapist, trainer, and the athlete. Often, it is the trainer who knows the athlete best and sees how they move and behave in a sport-specific setting. Participation should also start slowly and be increased gradually.

Athletes with cruciate ligaments injuries have an increased risk of sustaining a new cruciate ligament injury, both in their injured and their uninjured knee. Ongoing preventative training is therefore especially important for this group.

Return to sport

Even though there are examples of elite athletes returning to competitive sport in less than 6 months, such an aggressive rehabilitation training program is not recommended. The risk of another injury to the knee is increased after a cruciate ligament injury but can be reduced by taking the time for proper rehabilitation.